Friday, November 09, 2007

Would You Like A Bind Over for £50,000 Worth Of Criminal Damage?

The Crown Prosecution Service web site gives guidance on bind overs:

If circumstances justify, a prosecutor may invite the court to consider exercising its power to bind a defendant over as an alternative to prosecution for a criminal offence. The prosecutor should only invite the court to exercise this power once he has made a firm and settled decision to offer no evidence in the criminal proceedings.
In some courts this proposal is treated as an invitation for the court to act of its own motion. In other courts it is treated as a complaint laid under S115 MCA.

If treated as a S115 MCA complaint (which can be written or usually oral) the court may wish to hear evidence or require some proof of complaint. It is therefore in such circumstances necessary to ensure that some admissible evidence sufficient to prove the complaint is available.

Prosecutors should never invite the court to bind over anybody other than the defendant.


Do you think that a bind over would be an appropriate way to deal with £50,000 worth of criminal damage? Probably not.


I had the joy of dealing with an odd case recently. A family left their home to go away on a holiday, they left behind their son who is a teenager. The son has a party one night, and the following night some people went to the same address and have their own party. At the party £50,000 worth of damage was caused to the property as the vast majority of the furniture in the property was smashed up and thrown around.


I represented a number of people accused of criminally damaging the property. The evidence in this case consisted of forensic evidence that established that a number of people were at the address, but unfortunately the Crown Prosecution Service had no evidence that any individual who could be placed at the scene had actually damaged anything - mere presence in this case was not enough to prove the crime.


The Crown Prosecution Service wasted thousands of pounds on this case. They attempted to have this case sent for trial in the Crown Court by initially charging the defendants with burglary and criminal damage. The Crown Prosecution Service accepted after a few weeks that the evidence in their case was weak as it relied upon one witness. That witness was a person who went to the 'party' and said words to the effect that, "I was there but I didn't do anything. I left before anyone damaged anything, and when I got back the place was a mess." The Crown Prosecution Service dropped the case and after several months revived the case with the same weak evidence.


This case got all the way to a trial where two weeks had been set aside for the trial. The Crown Prosecution Service had clearly been concerned about the weakness in their evidence and instructed a barrister with 25 years experience to prosecute their case. Surprise, surprise their main witness who said, "I was there but I didn't do anything. I left before anyone damaged anything, and when I got back the place was a mess," did not turn up to give evidence. It was clear that the witness for the prosecution had not told the truth and that vast sums of money had been wasted preparing and prosecuting this case. Although the started it came grinding to a halt when the prosecution requested a short adjournment to find their witness.


Once the prosecution confirmed that they would not be in a position to locate their witness they asked if all the defendants in the case would like a bind over. Although there was some reluctance to accept bind overs where some defendants denied committing a crime, all defendants saw the logic in accepting a bind over which is not considered to be the same as a criminal conviction, rather than run the risk of a Magistrates Court convicting the defendants on the basis of mere presence at the scene.

16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hmmm.

I must say it sounds as productive a day as some of those I spend working in a local authority.

Are CPS prosecutors not trained in assessing the evidence before charging suspects?

Anonymous said...

Glad to see you back on the blogging trail Gavin. As a new Justice starting to sit in January I expect to gain some useful insights into the system from here.....

Millie said...

Not long ago i observed your site nevertheless get substantial an answer to this specific to hold in. Keep up the nice carry out, their particular nearly impossible to get beneficial people. We've combined with each of our faves. Plus the reasoning behind Many thanks. Millie

Agen Bola said...

This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work. I have been meaning to write something like this on my website and you have given me an idea. Agen Bola

Ford Makassar said...

Mate this is a very nice blog here. I wanted to comment & say that I enjoyed reading your posts & they are all very well written out. You make blogging look easy lol I’ll attemp to start a blog later today and I hope it’s half as good as your blog! Much success to you!

weddingplannerst.com said...

I agree with you. This post is truly inspiring. I like your post and everything you share with us is current and very informative, I want to bookmark the page so I can return here from you that you have done a fantastic job.

Living Room Design said...

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.

Judi Online said...

Thanks for the info, maybe I can use this ended my tufted marketing and I've been use untold anulus media in run a interaction and they someone existing a big amend on me.

Nine Ball said...

You may post on the professional credentials for the blog owner. You could express it's outstanding. Your blog experience can springboard your click through. Jurnal Sepak Bola

Wedding Planning Guide said...

Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something. I think that you could do with some pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this is great blog. A great read.

Bedroom Decorating Ideas said...

This is a fantastic website and I can not recommend you guys enough. Full of useful resource and great layout very easy on the eyes.

Agen Bola Online said...

Great blog! i actually love however it's straightforward on my eyes and also the info ar well written. i'm speculative however i would be notified whenever a brand new post has been created. I actually have signed to your rss feed that very ought to do the trick! Have a pleasant day!

00112358.net said...

I am extremely enjoying reading your well written articles. it's such as you pay plenty of effort and time on your web log. I actually have bookmarked it and that i am trying forward to reading new articles. Berita Sepak Bola

Ajax Voices said...

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. It looks like you spend a lot of effort and time on your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Taruhan Olahraga

Sport Betting Tips said...

This is a fantastic website and I can not recommend you guys enough. Full of useful resource and great layout very easy on the eyes. Soccer Betting Tips

InfoJudiTerkini said...

fantastis blog and hopefully everyone who coming here is find this useful foir them cheers

;Situs Judi Dota 2
Judi Esports
;Cara Bermain Judi Dota 2
Website Resmi Judi Dota 2
;Info Seputar Esports
Agen Judi Online Game
Esports Zone